Treat yourself to a fun surprise every other month! Join now

February 2018 - Medieval Mayhem

photo by @halfbloodfae

Exclusive Merlin "Your Destiny's Calling" Pouch, with artwork by Winnie Gong
Exclusive Xena: Warrior Princess Necklace, designed by the Gorgonist and created by Juniper and Ivy Designs
Advanced Reader Copy of "Tess of the Road" by Rachel Hartman Chainmail Nail Wraps by Espionage Cosmetics
Game of Thrones "Winter is Coming" Bronze Haircomb


December 2017 - Simply Marvelous

photo by @melodyltang

Spider-Gwen Infinity Scarf by BioWorld
Exclusive Black Panther Necklace by FanMail
Exclusive Thor: Ragnorak Tote Bag with artwork by Amelia Lo
Exclusive Jessica Jones Art Print by Varsha Vijayyan
Exclusive Spider-Man Sleep Mask by FanMail


October 2017 - Witch, Please!

photo by @bookhoarderproblems

Exclusive Harry Potter "Anything's Possible if You've Got Enough Nerve" Ginny Weasley Shirt by FanMail
Exclusive Sabrina the Teenage Witch "Pancake Madness" Apron by FanMail
"Black Cat Witch" Holographic Print by Jen Bartel
Kiki's Delivery Service "Jiji" Plush Keychain
Exclusive Hocus Pocus "Amok" Broomstick Pen
Bonus: Lunch Witch Comic and Trick-or-treat Item!
Exclusive Wiccapedia Booklet by FanMail

August 2017 - Leading Ladies

photo by @advinedebris

Exclusive Moana "There's Just No Telling How Far I'll Go" Shirt with artwork by Ev Angelo
Exclusive Orphan Black "Sestra" Bracelet by FanMail
Exclusive His Dark Materials "Alethiometer" Necklace with artwork by Hannah Hitchman
DC Bombshells Wonder Woman Umbrella
Game of Thrones "Danaerys Targaryen" Coasters (Set of 4)
Not Your Sidekick//Not Your Villain Bookmark by C.B. Lee


June 2017 - Just For Laughs

photo by @bookhoarderproblems

Exclusive Broad City Enamel Pin Exclusive
Parks and Recreation "Pawnee Goddesses" Shirt by FanMail
Exclusive Friends "I'll be there for you" Greeting Card Set (4!) designed by Temporary Places
Exclusive The Office "Dunder Mifflin" Travel Mug by FanMail
Print of Pam's Painting from The Office
Exclusive Mean Girls inspired "Burn Book" by FanMail
Exclusive Psych inspired "celebration kit" that includes a pineapple temporary tattoo, magnet, and pluto sticker by FanMail
The Princess Bride "Miracle Max's Miraculous Candle" from Calliope Candleworks


April 2017 - The Gang's All Here

photo by @fearyourex

Exclusive Star Wars "I Rebel" Beanie
Exclusive Charmed "Triquetra" Scarf
Exclusive Guardians of the Galaxy "Spirit in the Sky" Bath Bomb with charm inside by Nerdie Nifties
Harry Potter "The Golden Trio" Postcard
"Harlequin" Nail Wraps by Espionage Cosmetics
"The Spectacular Sisterhood of Superwomen" by Hope Nicholson Trading Cards OR Chaplet from Quirk Books
Exclusive "Rejected Princesses" Pin by FanMail and Trading Cards by Dey Street Books
Legend of Korra Sampler by Dark Horse Comics
The Werewolf Diaries by Amy Burzak Stickers
Contessa Bookmark and Pamphlet
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Coloring Book Page

February 2017 - Familiars and Companions

photo by @bookhoarderproblems

FanMail Exclusive "Star Wars" BB-8 Pillowcase
"Pokémon" Eevee-lution Plushie
Bookstr Journal & Bookmark
"Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find Them" Niffler Pouch with art by Snapdragon360
FanMail Exclusive "Doctor Who" Donna Noble Quote Sticker
FanMail Exclusive "Sailor Moon" Luna/Artemis Necklace

December 2016 - Legends of the CW 2.0

photo by @onthecyberseas

"The Flash" Versus "Supergirl" T-Shirt by Winnie Gong
"Buffy The Vampire Slayer" Chosen One Nail Wraps by Espionage Cosmetics
"Smallville" Talon Vinyl Coaster by FanMail
"Supernatural" Planner Sticker Sheets by FanMail
"Supernatural" Sam and Dean Winchester Business Cards by FanMail
Legends of the CW 2017 Calendar by Winnie Gong and FanMail
"Gilmore Girls" Luke's Diner Coffee Cup Insulator by FanMail
"Last Call at the Nightshade Lounge" by Paul Krueger Coaster


October 2016 - Things That Go Bump

photo by @stephaniebyday

“Teen Wolf” Evolution of Werewolf T-shirt by f0x-meets-w0lf
Upside Down Plant by Pine District
"Stranger Things" Mini-Pack by FanMail: Eggo Waffle Button, '11' Temporary Tattoos, and Christmas Lights Wall Magnet
Haunted Mansion Wallpaper Washi Tape by FanMail
"Ghostbusters" Screw U Necklace by FanMail
"How to Hang A Witch" by Adriana Mather Sampler
"My Best Friend's Exorcism" by Grady Hendrix Sticker
"Supernatural" Dean Winchester and Dracula Print
Geek Girl Pen Pals Print by Jordandené

August 2016 - The Happiest Box on Earth

photo by @ivy.booknerd

FanMail Exclusive "Mulan" Shirt and Art Print, design by Christy Hartman
"Lilo & Stitch" Stitch Magnetic Bottle Opener
"Maleficent" Vinyl Dorbz Collectible by Funko
"Big Hero 6" Baymax Necklace
Mystery "Disney" Heroes/Villians Keychain by Monogram International

June 2016 - Our 1st Anniversary!

photo by @fictionfood

"Daredevil" Shirt by FanMail
"Harry Potter" Sorcerer's Stone Necklace
& Weasleys' Wizard Wheezes Bag by FanMail
"Merlin" Pendragon Coin Purse by FanMail
"Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy" Don't Panic Towel by FanMail
"Parks and Recreation" Decal by Fairy Dust Decals , design by Christy Hartman
"X-Men: First Class" Keychain
"Betty & Veronica" Postcard Set

May 2016 - Magical Mystery

photo by @hufflepuffpages

“Peter Pan” Temporary Tattoo by Litographs
“Charmed” ‘P3’ Nightclub Shirt by FanMail
“Harry Potter” Hermione Pocket Pop! Keychain by Funko
“Once Upon a Time” Belle’s Cup Necklace
& Printed Purple Bag by FanMail
FanMail Exclusive “Pushing Daisies” The Pie Hole Candle by SnowsCutSoaps (apple pie scented!)
"Penny Dreadful” Comic Book #1 (First Printing)
“Julia Vanishes” by Catherine Egan Sampler
FanMail Exclusive “Magical Miyazaki” Art Print by Tziporah Thompson

April 2016 - This Means War!

photo by @bildungsromans

"Game of Thrones" Targaryen Dragon Bracelet
"Consider" by Kristy Acevedo Signed Bookmark
”Batman vs Superman" Lapel Pin Set by FanMail
"Doctor Who"/"Rocky Horror Picture Show" Ceramic Coaster Set by FanMail
"Star Wars" Cosmetic Bag by FanMail ( buy it now! )
"Mad Max: Fury Road" Pencil Quote Set by FanMail
"Winner's Trilogy" by Marie Rutkoski Lip Balm
FanMail Exclusive "Civil Sandbox" Shirt & Art Print by Ranta
"And I Darken" by Kiersten White Sampler

March 2016 - Mostly Dead

photo by @fictionfood

"The Nightmare Before Christmas" Sally Mopeez by Funko
"Shaun of the Dead" Winchester Tavern Shotglass by FanMail
"Buffy the Vampire Slayer" or "Angel" Minibust
They came in Drusilla, Vampire Dru, or Vampire Angelus - and some of them are signed on their bases by the amazing sculptor Clay Moore!
Previews Exclusive "Words with Zombies" Fridge Magnets
FanMail Exclusive “iZombie" Meat Cute Sticker by 10&Under;
"The Walking Dead" Tote Bag by FanMail
FanMail Exclusive ”iZombie" Liv Moore Print by Maggie Atkinson

February 2016 - Cracking the Case

photo by @hypable

“Hannibal” Drink the Rude Mini-Goblet by FanMail
“Daredevil” Nelson & Murdock Pocket Notebook by FanMail
“Paper Girls” Comic Book #1 (First Printing)
“The X-Files” Replica Case File by 10&Under;
“Sherlock” Hound of the Baskervilles Shirt by Risa Rodil
“Veronica Mars” Inkworks Promotional Cards
FanMail Exclusive “Elementary” Clyde the Turtle Necklace
“Jessica Jones” Alias Investigations Business Card by FanMail
“The X-Files” I Want to Believe - Mulder’s Poster Print by FanMail
“The Darkest Corners” by Kara Thomas Sampler

Bonus: 100 subscribers received an Advanced Reader’s Copy of “The Darkest Corners” by Kara Thomas , and 35 of them received extra promotional materials for the book as well!

January 2016 - Galentines & Valentines

FanMail Exclusive “Orphan Black” Sestrahood of the Traveling Genes Nail Wraps by Espionage Cosmetics
“The Princess Bride” As You Wish Shirt by FanMail
FanMail Exclusive “Outlander” Claire’s Wedding Rings Necklace
“Truthwitch” by Susan Dennard Map
FanMail Exclusive “Galentines & Valentines” Greeting Cards Set by Christy Hartman feat. quotes from “Parks & Recreation”, “Game of Thrones”, “Captain America” & “Doctor Who” ( buy them now! )
FanMail Exclusive “Jessica Jones” Art Print by Winnie Gong
“Red Queen” Sampler by Victoria Aveyard

Bonus: 40 subscribers received an Advanced Reader’s Copy of “A Gathering of Shadows” by V.E. Schwab

December 2015 - Toon Time

photo by @_dynahsaur

FanMail Exclusive “Lumberjanes” #21 & Art Print by Carey Pietsch ( buy it now! )
“Big Hero 6” Baymax Free Hugs Shirt by FanMail
“Bee & Puppycat” Plush Puppycat by Squishable
FanMail Exclusive “Steven Universe” Garnet Flavored Lip Tint by Fictitious Fragrances (blue raspberry flavor!)
“Toon Time” Button Set by FanMail feat. Tina from “Bob’s Burgers,” Bill Cipher from “Gravity Falls,” Appa from “Avatar: The Last Airbender,” Fionna & Cake from “Adventure Time”
Special 'I'm the Doctor, Not a Companion' Button from “The Fangirl’s Guide to the Galaxy” by Sam Maggs

November 2015 - Wars Among the Stars

“Star Wars” True Believers: Princess Leia Comic Book #1
“Star Wars” Stormtrooper Lapel Pins by FanMail
FanMail Exclusive “Wars Among the Stars” Coloring Book with illustrations by Winnie Gong
“Guardians of the Galaxy” Convention Exclusives Comic Book
“The Lunar Chronicles” by Marissa Meyer Temporary Tattoo Sheet
“Star Wars” Death Star Soap by Amethyst Soaps
“Guardians of the Galaxy” We Are Groot Shirt & Art Print by Risa Rodil

October 2015 - Yay for Y.A.!

photo by @fictionfood

“Harry Potter” Ollivander’s Shirt & Art Print by FanMail
“Percy Jackson” Shield of Athena Necklace
“The Golden Compass” Iorek Byrnison & Lyra Silvertongue Magnetic Bookmark by BeeDooTo
“Harry Potter” Luna Lovegood Magnetic Bookmark by BeeDooTo
“A Series of Unfortunate Events” V.F.D. Handchain
“Hunger Games” Greeting Cards
“The Maze Runner” WICKD Temporary Tattoo by FanMail
“Divergent” Tris Birds Temporary Tattoo by FanMail
“A Thousand Pieces of You” by Claudia Gray Bookmark & Poster
“Truthwitch” by Susan Dennard Button
Tor Books Sampler Download
Signed bookplates by Marie Lu , Sarah Fine , Lori M. Lee
Halloween-themed “Little Vamplets” or “Archie & Friends” Comics

Bonus: Subscribers received a random extra item - a “Hunger Games” Mockingjay Light Bulb, “Hunger Games” Votive Glass, “Hunger Games” Mockingjay Beanie, “Hunger Games” Shirt, or “Twilight” Apple Photoholder by CineQuest

September 2015: Legends of the CW

photo by @stephaniebyday

Supernatural” Hunters Shirt by Risa Rodil
“Buffy the Vampire Slayer” Faith or Cordelia Ornament
FanMail Exclusive “Arrow” Felicity Smoak Replica Necklace
“Supernatural” Sam Winchester’s Army Man by FanMail
“The Flash” CC Jitters Coffee Insulator Sleeve by FanMail
Classic Inkworks Promo Cards
“Supernatural” Kansas License Plate Necklace
FanMail Exclusive “Buffy Summers” Art Print by Maggie Atkinson
Stickers from Various CW shows

Bonus: 20 subscribers received autographs cards from CW stars!

August 2015: Super Sheroes

photo by @ohjaechaos

FanMail Exclusive “Super Sheroes” Magnetic Bookmarks Set feat. Spider-Gwen, Storm, Lady Thor by Beedooto
“Batman/Superman” Necklace
“Wonder Woman” Rubber Wristband
“Black Canary” Comic Book #1 (First Printing) - some subscribers got retailer exclusive covers!
“Super Sheroes” Button Set feat. Raven, Ms. Marvel, Black Widow, Batgirl by FanMail
“Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D” Melinda May Pop! Vinyl Figure by Funko

July 2015: Out of This World

photo by @jasujo

“Intergalactic Curses” Shirt by FanMail
“Star Trek” Enterprise Docking Permit by Lisa at 10&Under;
“The 100” Logo Button by FanMail
“Firefly” Curse Your Sudden But Inevitable Betrayal Button by FanMail
“Doctor Who” Spinning TARDIS Pendant Necklace
“Alien vs. Predator” Expandable Alien Ring
“Farscape” Mini-Drak Figurine
“Doctor Who” TARDIS Tote Bag

Bonus: Origami Sheets with instructions to make Wash’s dinosaurs from “Firefly”

June 2015: Legends & Lore

photo by @alexaraye323

“How to Train Your Dragon” Toothless Shirt by FanMail
“Game of Thrones” Purple Wedding Invitation by FanMail
“The Hobbit” Thranduil Brooch
Regina from “Once Upon a Time” and Gandalf from “Lord of the Rings” Button Set by FanMail
“Harry Potter” Nail Decals Set by BKM Vinyl Designs
Hogwarts Crest Button by FanMail
“Legend of Zelda” Triforce Necklace
“Harry Potter” Sorcerer’s Stone Soap by Amethyst Soaps

SDCC Exclusives

San Diego Comic-Con 2017 Exclusive Heroine Complex Box

"Heroine Complex" by Sarah Kuhn
"Heroine Worship" by Sarah Kuhn
2 Signed Bookplates
A letter from Sarah Kuhn
Jordandene "Girl Power" Sticker Pack
Giant Robot "Spam Musubi" Enamel Pin & "Soup Dumpling" Enamel Pin
"Girl Gang" Holographic Print by Jen Bartel
Monster Cupcake Soap by SnowsCutSoaps
Monster Cupcake Tote & Button (art by Sina Grace)


"Ladies of the Con 2.0" San Diego Comic-Con 2016 Exclusive Mystery Bundle

Fan Mail Exclusive "Game of Thrones" 'All Men Must Die, But We Are Not Men' Tote Bag, design by Christy Hartman ( buy it now! )
FanMail Exclusive "Harry Potter" 'Mione's Magical Mani (Hermione Granger-inspired) Nail Wraps by Espionage Cosmetics
FanMail Exclusive "Ladies of the Con" Cosplay Trading Card Set
"Arrow" Bracelet
& Speedy Jewelry Bag by FanMail
"DC Bombshells" Sublimated Pom Beanie by BioWorld
"Legend of Korra" Waterbender Infinity Scarf by FanMail

The bundle also included our
FanMail Exclusive Convention Survival Kit:

"Spider-Gwen" 'With Great Power...' Power Brick by FanMail
FanMail Exclusive "Game of Thrones" 'All Men Must Die, But We Are Not Men' Cosmetics Bag, design by
Christy Hartman
"Harry Potter" Mirror of Erised Pocket Mirror by FanMail
"Mad Max: Fury Road" AquaCola Flexible Water Bottle by FanMail
FanMail Band-Aid Dispenser, Pen, & Hand Sanitizer Spray


"Ladies of the Con" San Diego Comic-Con 2015 Exclusive Mystery Box

SDCC Exclusive "Orphan Black" Road Trip to San Diego Comic Book by IDW Publishing
"iZombie" #1 First-Printing Comic Book
Mystery Lady Funko Pop! Vinyl Figure by Funko (Sansa Stark, Arya Stark, Cersei Lannister, Ygritte, Brienne of Tarth, Daenerys Targaryen, Zoe Washburne, Buffy Summers, Willow Rosenberg, and Nebula)
Felicia Day's "The Guild" Trading Card Pack
"Vampire Diaries" Katherine's Pendant Necklace
"Orphan Black" Sestra T-shirt by FanMail
"Game of Thrones" Sansa Stark Dragonfly Necklace

FanMail Favorites

All the Crooked Saints

photo by @hayaisreading

Hardcover copy of " All the Crooked Saints " by Maggie Stiefvater
Signed bookplate with art by Maggie Stiefvater
Letter to the reader from Maggie Stiefvater
Pillowcase with art by Miranda Davila
Tote bag with art by KDP Letters
Canvas Art Print by Andrea Montano
Diablo Diablo sticker by FanMail
Cover Art Print


photo by @bildungsromans

Hardcover copy of Warcross by Marie Lu
Letter and signed bookplate from Marie Lu
Signed portrait of Emika Chen by Marie Lu
Warcross team player hand-stamped bracelet by The Colorful Geek Phoenix Riders notebook by FanMail
Emika Chen magnetic bookmark by Beedoo.TO
Warcross logo keychain and bookmark
Phoenix Riders candle by Meraki Candles
Temporary Tattoo and Art Print by FanMail


photo by @diamondxgirl

Hardcover copy of " Geekerella " by Ashley Poston
Signed "VIP Excelsicon Pass" Bookplate & Letter to the Reader by Ashley Poston
"Wabba Wabba Cereal Treats" Recipe by @fictionfood
Exclusive Elle & Darien Bookmarks by HappyHelloCo
Exclusive "Magic Pumpkin" Candle by SnowsCutSoaps
"Look to the Stars. Aim. Ignite!" Tote Bag designed by Ashley Poston
Frank the Dog Keychain
"Starfield" Logo Decal designed by Ashley Poston
Geekerella Poster by Quirk Books

Harry Potter

photo by sneirrbooks

House Colors Infinity Scarf by FanMail
Sorting Hat Candle with House Charm by Snows Cut Soap
House Prefect Badge
House Mug by FanMail
"Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find Them" Newt Scamander Magnetic Bookmark by BeedooTO
Snitch Earrings

Wonder Women

photo by @dreamersinful

"Wonder Women: 25 Innovators, Inventors, and Trailblazers Who Changed History" by Sam Maggs
"Wonder Women" Poster
Letter to the reader from Sam Maggs
Signed bookplate
"Ada Lovelace" Gold Pin by Auberg Designs
Art print of Noor Inayat Khan by Rori Comics
Double-sided tote bag with Bessie Coleman & Brita Tott quotes by FanMail ( buy it now! )
Gal Pals, Sailor Moon, The Craft, and Witchy Vibes Buttons by FanMail
Samplers for "The Fangirl's Guide to the Galaxy" by Sam Maggs and "Crafting with Feminism" by Bonnie Burton

Supernatural: Round Two

photo by @dreamersinful

"Swan Song" San Diego Comic-Con Exclusive 1:18 Impala with Sam's Army Man by
One of: Bloody Dean Winchester/Sam Winchester/Crowley Pop! Vinyl Figure by Funko & Convention Exclusives
FanMail Exclusive "Supernatural" T-shirt, design by Ranta
Trading Card Pack from Seasons 3-7
Dean Winchester's Ring Necklace by
"Supernatural" Challenge Coin Replica
Winchester Road Map by Lisa at 10&Under;
Winchester Brothers Business Card by FanMail
"Supernatural" Dean Winchester & Universal Monsters Postcard
"Supernatural" the Magazine (Various Issues)

Doctor Who: Round Two

photo by @chantellie_rose

Pom Tardis Beanie
Dalek Crew Socks
Bad Wolf Crew Socks
"Doctor Who" Official Magazine (Various Issues)
"Torchwood" Official Magazine (Various Issues)
The 10th Doctor Pop! Vinyl by Funko
The 11th Doctor Pop! Vinyl by Funko
"Doctor Who" Sticker Pack by GetGlue
'I Am The Doctor, Not a Companion' Button from "The Fangirl's Guide to the Galaxy" by Sam Maggs
"Doctor Who"  10th Doctor Comic Book

Firefly: Round Two

photo by @tinkerbellpixee

Mystery "Firefly" Pop! Vinyl Figure by Funko
"Leaf on the Wind" Keychain by QMx
Legacy Figure: Jayne Cobb
Reaction Figure: Mal Reynolds or Kaylee Frye
"Firefly" Promo Card by Inkworks
Serenity the ship Mini-Plush
Serenity Replica Money by Lisa at 10&Under;

Buffy the Vampire Slayer & Angel the Series: Round Two

"Buffy" Card Set by Inkworks
Buffy "Buffybot" 6" Action Figure
Oz T1 Prototype Figure
"Buffy" Official Magazine (Various Issues)
"Angel" Official Magazine (Various Issues)
"Buffy the Vampire Slayer" Comic Book (Various Issues)
"Buffy the Vampire Slayer" Willow Comic Book (Various Issues)
Buffy/Angel Promo Cards
Reaction Figure: Buffy Summers
"Buffy" Collage Art Print by Sabrina Zaremba
Amber Benson's "Chance" Movie Poster
Amber Benson's "Chance" Music CD


Felicity Smoak Action Figure
Arrow Lego Minifigure
Arrow Bangle Cuff Bracelet
Arrow Logos Button Set
Queen Consolidated Parking Sticker by Fanatic Goods
Superhero Cities Map by Fanatic Goods
Oliver Queen For Mayor Magnets
Verdant Opening Night Flyer by Fanatic Goods


Orphan Black

"I Heart Cosima" Necklace
Retailer Exclusive Orphan Black Comic Book
SDCC Exclusive Orphan BlackFunko Pop! Vinyl
Hot Topic Exclusive Orphan Black Funko Pop! Vinyl
Helsinki Complete 5 Comic Set
Vote for Alison Hendrix Magnet
Sestrahood of the Travelling Genes Nail Wraps
Orphan Black Button Set


Grimm Lunchbox
Coin of Zakynthos Replica
Grimm Pin Set
Grimm Skull Logo Patch
Grimm Map of 7 Keys
Grimm Replica Shot Glasses
Grimm Playing Cards
Carded Grimm Sticker Pack

Ready to subscribe?